A contract has conditions. You hold up your end, I hold up mine. If circumstances change enough, the contract can be renegotiated or dissolved. That is a reasonable arrangement for most agreements.
A vow is different.
A vow is made precisely because circumstances will change. It assumes the worse will come. It is not a bet that things will go well. It is a promise to stay when they don't.
December 4, 2015. 9am. Jim Allison and Anna Warren came to Weaver First United Methodist Church before the ceremony. I asked them the questions I always asked: Why do you want to be married? What do you believe about marriage? How will your families feel?
They answered. Jim had cancer. They both knew. Anna knew what the odds were. She had found her answer before she ever called to ask me to officiate.
Four o'clock, same sanctuary. Small group. Shirt and tie. No program. No unity candle. Just the two of them and the witnesses, and the words.
She married him anyway.
Most couples getting married cannot feel the weight of what they are promising. Not because they are avoiding it — because they cannot see it yet. You cannot fully understand what you are promising until you have lived inside the promise long enough to be tested. That is true for everyone who has ever stood at an altar.
But you can get closer to understanding it before you stand there.
Here is what I have learned, both from officiating weddings and from being inside one: the couples who stay together are not the ones who never hurt each other. They are the ones who know how to find each other again after they do.
Every marriage ruptures. That is not a failure of the marriage. It is what happens between two people living in close proximity under real pressure. The rupture is not the problem. Not having a way back is the problem.
Our repair loop is not elegant. It often starts with someone saying something awkward, or walking into the kitchen to offer a hug when neither of us is ready, or just saying: I don't want to be fighting. It does not always work on the first try. But we have a door. We know where it is. After a hard night, one of us always reaches for it eventually.
That is the promise, lived out on a Tuesday.
A theologian named Robert Jenson wrote that in an age when our culture has lost faith in promise-keeping, the church could be an outpost of promises made and kept. Not a place of perfection. An outpost. A community that holds the promise even when the people inside it are failing at it.
That is the real function of the witnesses at a wedding. You are not just asking them to watch. You are asking them to hold something with you. When you forget what you promised, or when you are too tired or too hurt to hold it yourself, the witnesses remember.
Anna and Jim had a small group. But they had witnesses. And they had a room that had held a lot of promises before theirs — some kept, some broken, all of them real.
Not the unity candle at the wedding.
The candle you light on a Tuesday in February when the kids are finally in bed and neither of you feels like it. The one you light anyway because you decided — before the wedding, in a conversation like this one — that this was the practice you were keeping.
That candle is the vow. Not the ceremony version. The Tuesday version.
The Tuesday version is what you are actually promising.
Before you stand at the altar, name one specific worse — something that has already happened in your relationship, or something you can see coming. Name your repair sentence together. Not a script. A door. Something one of you can say after a hard fight that signals: I still want to be in this.
It does not have to be poetic. It just has to be true.
Start with the promises session in Tend.
Tend is a six-session premarital program delivered by text, email, or on screen. Free to start.
Start Tend →